She sits, puts her phone face-down on the table, and says she’s here for help with her anxiety. She tells me that her chest gets tight on Sunday nights as she lies awake doing math on her own life—the friend who bought another house, the sister who’s pregnant again, the roommate who just launched a podcast. Then she says the sentence you’ve probably heard a hundred times: “I feel like everyone else’s life is happening, and mine isn’t.”
Her intake form says anxiety. Her vocabulary suggests fear as the main issue, but it seems more like a desire for what she doesn’t have. And because she’s under forty, there’s a branded name for it—FOMO (The Fear of Missing Out). But before I can help her, I have to answer one diagnostic question: do I believe her self-diagnosis?
In my two decades of ministry, no one has ever called the church office to schedule an appointment with me about their covetousness. Not once. And yet, I’ve spent thousands of hours sitting with people who struggle with coveting. It just never comes in wearing its own name. This woman was struggling with exactly that—wanting what she didn’t have and being discontented with it.
Trace the Smoke to the Fire
Let’s use smoke as an illustration. Smoke always rises from something, so it never lies about whether there’s a fire—but smoke is also never where the fire is, so it distracts from the source. You cannot put out smoke. You can only use it as a guide to determine what is actually burning. As counselors, that is our job—not to get distracted by the smoke or try to extinguish it, but to find the burning source.
Anxiety, envy, comparison, the fear of missing out— these struggles are smoke, in many cases. They may be real emotions, but they are not the fire. Scripture is never shy about naming what burns: “…out of the heart come evil thoughts” (Matt. 15:19).
As we strive to help the heart of the counselee, we must not forget that the words we use to describe the problem matter so much in this work. Why? Because the words we choose determine the source of the issue we seek to solve.
If this woman’s problem is genuine fear, she needs comfort—the Bible commands us to comfort those who are afraid.
But if, beneath the smoke, she’s actually struggling with envy, comforting her would be bad counseling; the envious must be confronted.
If we diagnose incorrectly, we’ll spend countless sessions backpedaling with no progress made.
There is a quiet deceptive genius in relabeling, and our whole culture is in on it. Call it FOMO, and you’ve created a victim—fear is something that happens to me. Call it covetousness, and you’re counseling a violator—the tenth commandment is something I do (Exod. 20:17). Relabeling a sin as an emotion feels like mercy—it’s actually theft. We take from our counselee the only door out. You can’t repent of missing out. You can repent of envy.
Underneath the smoke you’ll usually find one of three fires, and you’ll meet all three soon in your counseling office:
- Envy: wanting what we don’t have—it “makes the bones rot” (Prov. 14:30).
- Discontentment: having what we don’t want, which survives only on selective amnesia—to grumble at Kadesh, Israel had to forget the Red Sea (Num. 14).
- Pride: thinking of ourselves.—pride is the gasoline; comparison is just where it pools.
Where Contentment Actually Lives
This woman came into my office hoping I’d endorse her treatment plan (i.e., the world’s plan):
“help me change the circumstance,”
“tell me how to gain what I lack,” or
“instruct me to numb the desire.”
But think about it biblically—Israel got the most spectacular change of circumstances in history, their prayers were answered, and still they were nostalgic for Egypt within pages; gaining more does not silence the ache (Luke 12:15); and numbing the desire is tape over the check-engine light. Scripture never prescribes anesthesia—Paul wept, Jesus wept, and the Psalms hand us a whole vocabulary for wanting. Self-prescribed treatment plans do not often reflect what the Bible is truly trying to teach us—a practice that feels foreign: contentment.
But if the goal is contentment, where does it actually live? Go ask Paul who was sitting in a Roman prison— Philippians 4:13 may be the most printed and least understood verse in the canon.[1] Read it in context, and two things surface.
First, contentment is learned: “I have learned… to be content” (Phil. 4:11). It is not downloaded in a moment of surrender but learned over time, in a classroom of life where the curriculum asks us to be “brought low” and live “abounding” (v. 12).
Second, contentment is not self-sufficiency: Paul borrows the Stoics’ favorite word for “content” and detonates it—”I can do all things through him who strengthens me” (vs. 13). Sufficiency is sourced outside the self.
Now, you might be thinking, “But where is contentment learned? I want to give my counselee tangible advice on how to go about this process.”
Philippians won’t tell you where Paul learned it. For that, go back to 2 Corinthians 12, where he highlights a thorn he never names—a thorn that fits every issue you and your counselee face: the chronic pain, the empty crib, the child who won’t call. Watch what he does: “Three times I pleaded with the Lord… that it should leave me” (v. 8).
The most contented man in the New Testament begged God to change his circumstances—out loud, three times. So let’s retire the notion that contentment and lament are enemies. Contentment that has never pleaded isn’t contentment. It’s numbness with a memory verse.
Then God answers—not with removal, but with a sentence: “My grace is sufficient for you” (v. 9). Here’s the center of it: the word for “sufficient” here and the word for “content” in Philippians 4:11 share a root.[2] Paul asked God to change the circumstance; God changed Paul’s sufficiency instead. The thorn was the classroom; Philippians 4 is the diploma. Contentment is not the absence of the thorn. It is the presence of sufficient grace. And it wasn’t free—another man pleaded three times in a garden (Matt. 26:44), and the Father told the sinless Son “no” so He could tell Paul, and you, and the woman in your office, my grace is enough. Contentment isn’t a technique. It’s a communion.
Three Moves for Your Next Counselee
Perceive. Don’t argue with the label; get underneath it. Three questions do more work than any worksheet:
- What do you believe you must have to be okay? (Idolatry often masquerades as necessity.)
- When the fear spikes, what are you afraid of missing? (Name the object, name the treasure—Matt. 6:21.)
- Finish this: “I could be content if—.” (Whatever fills the blank is sitting in Christ’s seat.)
Then discern: fear or envy? From that discernment, you can then gently confront the coveting and then lavishly comfort those who are honest. But never comfort instead of confrontation. Don’t water the weed.
Pray. Let the book of James run the intake: “You do not have, because you do not ask… you ask wrongly, to spend it on your passions” (James 4:2–3). Some counselees hyperfixate on a desire, weep over it, journal about it—and never once ask God. Others ask, but it’s a vending-machine prayer with the idol as the product. The first needs to learn to ask; the second needs their desires discipled, not deleted. Either way you’re teaching Gethsemane grammar: let this cup pass; yet not as I will (Matt. 26:39). Lament fully; surrender fully—same prayer.
Practice. Assign the coursework for learned contentment. Have your counselees write five to seven answers to one question—What has Christ given me that nothing and no one else can?—and carry the list everywhere. Give them the gratitude runway of Philippians 4:4–9, and two or three texts to take the comparison-thought captive the moment it fires. That war is won or lost in the three seconds between the trigger and the spiral; willpower, alone, loses every time.
Repentance, gratitude, prayerful dependence—and a joy that outlasts the circumstance, because it was never sourced there in the first place. That’s the secret worth handing them on their way out the door: He is enough. Now go teach it.
[1] The verse appears widely on mugs, posters, and athletic gear divorced from its context; the surrounding paragraph (Phil. 4:10–13) is about facing “plenty and hunger, abundance and need,” not personal achievement.
[2] The Greek term rendered “content” in Philippians 4:11 (autarkēs) is built on the same verb (arkeō) behind God’s word “sufficient” (arkei) in 2 Corinthians 12:9. The parable of the culture-as-accomplice detective and the framing of covetousness beneath emotional “smoke” are indebted to David Powlison, Seeing with New Eyes: Counseling and the Human Condition through the Lens of Scripture (Phillipsburg, NJ: P&R Publishing, 2003).
Hear more from Josh at our 2027 Summer Institute next July in Santa Clarita, CA. Click here for details and to register!
